patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Teachers Leaving District For More Money

Superintendent Bill Olsen said the trend is growing.

 

At least five or six teachers are leaving the district for higher paying jobs.

Superintendent of Schools Everett "Bill" Olsen Jr. told the Lowell Sun, he began to notice this trend about four or five years ago, but this summer there has been an increase in the number of staff who have left.

According to the Lowell Sun article, a physics teacher at Westford Academy left to teach in another district that will pay about $7,000 more than Westford. An assistant principal left Westford to accept a job that will pay $17,000 more.

Before the end of the school year, teachers and the School Committee were locked in contract negotiations which finally resulted in a three-year contract being signed. 

Related Topics: Schools, Westford Teachers, and Westford Teachers Contract

Tony

7:09 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I said all last year we were going to be seeing plenty more of this due to Westford wanting first class teachers while paying less than competitive salaries. Now I have heard of a few teachers who left WPS this summer and didn't make it known why ($) so those teachers are not the ones counted here. I also have heard of half dozen or so teachers at the high school looking for jobs in better paying districts now.
The contract might have been settled but nearly ALL teachers do not feel it was a fair offer and it only increased the salary disparity between WPS and our neighbors.

Mark my words the trickle will turn to an exodus when the $ gap is coupled with administration mistreating employees contract rights (personal days)

The end result will be more inexperienced teachers in a short period of time in Westford and choice candidates look elsewhere for openings

Comment_arrow

Jessica

3:55 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

And the entire town will suffer. For years people have moved to Westford for the great school system. Now that teachers are leaving, we are unable to hire the cream of the crop because we don't offer a competitive pay. The quality of the school system will gradually decline until Westford will no longer be known for its great schools system.
I grew up in this school system, and I am so incredibly prepared for college because of it. I hate to see this happening, the children in the elementary system and middle school system know will enter the high school in the shadow of what it used to be. Such a shame.

Sam

7:31 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

5-6 people out of 600 seems low. Do you have past year's data to back up your claim

Comment_arrow

Vincent DiRico

7:44 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

There isn't even any data to back-up the "nearly ALL teachers do not feel it was a fair offer " claim -> they voted to accept it! all while stating we will crush you before a judge, ... the bitter who post here are just that bitter, they hide and say whatever they like (no data/facts needed).

Franklin

8:01 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Just a few points:
My understanding is many teachers accepted because they were fearful of going into another year with no contract NOT because they felt 'this is fair'. Yes, they accepted it.
There are NOT 600 teachers in WPS there are closer to 400 (Aides do not vote on contract they are not part of same bargaining unit). Yes, 5-6 is low but the point is it is 2-3x that number this past year and I bet there will be another half dozen teachers from WPS who secure last minute jobs at the end of August in better paying towns and leave before the start o September. I also believe (from conversations with teachers in town) they this year MANY more experienced standout teachers will look to test the job markets outside of WPS...You can bury head in the same all you want and say the sky isnt blue and water isnt wet but this was a logical result of the past year.
WPS administrators should be fully ready for employees who used to 'go with the flow' and not read line for line in their contract to have a new outlook thanks to the past year. There was a way things were done (mutual respect) before in Westford and now the result of the past year is that there is likely a new way of doing business. The SC has made its bed and now its time to sleep in it, 'the chickens are coming home to roost'.
Many teachers at WA are very aware of the last day of the year failure to respect/follow contract language with some employees by Admin, Not a good way to mend damaged fences I would say!

Franklin

8:06 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Please keep in mind this isnt just the teachers saying they are aware of many more leaving Westford over the towns cheapness and bully tactics at the table, this is now Superintendent Olsen as well!
When all the sudden students have a brand new teacher hired the last week of August from the 2nd (3rd) tier of condidates because the teacher they were set to have found a better paying job elsewhere at the last minute dont be shocked!

Julie C.

8:59 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

A mere 3 years ago, Westford hired 40 new teachers.

From the information I've seen over the past ten years, Westford Academy sends approximately 10% of its graduating seniors to one of the 50 USNWR top-ranked universities or to one of the 50 USNWR top-ranked liberal arts colleges. Another 40% attend UMass / Mass state college / Mass community college. The rest go to other (including less-selective) colleges / into the workforce / into the military. The conclusion I come to is that the very intelligent kids will do well no matter who is teaching a class. Many parents in Westford are willing to pay for extra-curricular classes / online programs so kids can ace the SATs and AP tests and write compelling essays for the more competitive colleges. My guess is that this won't change because the top students are self-motivated and will seek to do well no matter what.
And as for the rest of the students, the public school curriculum is geared towards educating the average student. To quote Franklin above, a "2nd (3rd) tier" candidate (whatever that is) is probably adequate to gain admission to a state college, which is where a vast number of Westford graduates end up.
Of course I understand that choosing to go to a state school or community college could simply be for financial reasons, but that would simply underscore the fact that Westford is not an ultra-wealthy community and should not be compared to towns that have a much higher tax base.

Comment_arrow

Bonnie

10:11 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

WA has had 95% - 98% of its students go on to attend 2 or 4 year colleges over the past 4 years. Because a student does not attend a "top ranked" university does not mean that they are not as intelligent or motivated as students who do attend "top ranked" universities. There are many factors that students consider when choosing colleges and universities including program of studies, finances, and location.

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

9:25 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Bonnie, I agree 100% with everything you wrote. A lot does go into a student's decision about where to attend college. My point is that many people contend Westford has to hire the best and the "cream of the crop" to teach our children, but if we as a town have financial constraints, then that might not be feasible if the "best" teachers demand more and more money. (And from my kids' experiences with teachers in the Westford schools, I would only classify about 15% of them as being "the best." You can check out students' ratings of their teachers on RateMyTeacher dot com. You might be surprised.) Should I pay exhorbitant taxes to the town and then have to send my kids to community college because I can't afford a four-year college? I'd prefer to pay reasonable taxes and then supplement my kids' education with programs that interest them. The way I see it, Westford's teachers are not the primary factor in my children's success. Academic success (or "preparation for college or life" or however anyone wants to label it) is far more dependent on the student and his/her family than on the teacher. A motivated student will always strive to do well, no matter who is teaching a class.

Jon Myerov

9:41 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

What do I want in a teacher? I want someone who knows a lot about the subject(s) s/he teaches. I want someone who understands the diverse kinds of children in class, the many learning styles they have, and the many pressures they face. I want someone who puts care, thought, and work into lessons, grading, and daily interaction. I want someone who exudes energy, enthusiasm, and genuine love of learning. I want someone who models intellectual curiosity and who teaches not only raw content but ways of approaching the subjects. I want someone who leads and exemplifies leadership, someone who exhibits strength of character. I want someone who looks out for students, who listens to them, and who engages them. I want someone who brings out the best in my children.

I put my children in Westford Public Schools not because of any private or public university they may attend but because I want them to graduate with a desire to continue gaining knowledge, skill, and experience. I want them to leave excited that there's much more to know. And long after they leave WPS, I want them to be able to look back at their teachers and be proud to have been influenced by people of education, integrity, and civic responsibility.

The teachers I want in WPS are not rare. I've met many of them. And having met them and talked with them, I feel strongly they deserve to be paid competitively against their peers in neighboring towns. Their value to Westford goes way beyond the classroom.

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

11:04 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Wow, Jon, you expect a lot from teachers. Maybe that's why so many of them feel they are underpaid.
I feel it's my job as a parent to instill a love of learning in my children. (And I know it's easier with some children than with others.) Teachers should be there to teach their subject(s). Parents should be responsible for fostering intellectual curiosity, exemplifying leadership and strength of character, and enforcing discipline. Or maybe I'm just old-fashioned.

Comment_arrow

Jon Myerov

12:55 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Julie C.,

Yes, I expect a lot from teachers. I've been a teacher. It's a profession like any other, and if one wants to be good in one's profession, there are many different aspects to master. My experience and observation in Westford is that we have very many teachers who are professionals. What they do in the actual classroom is only one part of all the work: in many cases, it really is a 24/7 job. Even when school is out.

So, yeah, I expect a lot from teachers. I expect a lot from my children. I expect a lot from myself. What the heck are we doing if not trying to move forward?

Comment_arrow

Bonnie

10:09 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

There is a big difference between a teacher who can stand in the front of the room and deliver the subject material and one that not only teaches the subject material but can engage the students and make them excited about learning; who can challenge the students and get the students to reach insides of themselves to reach heights they never thought they were capable of. Yes parents can and do instill a love of learning. But teachers also need to reinforce that love of learning. Students with teachers who only teach the material will disengage and can over time lose that love of learning and become demotivated. We have been fortunate in Westford to have many teachers in Westford who are able to engage their students and motivate them to continue on a path of learning. These are the teachers that Westford is at the highest risk of losing to other towns.

Comment_arrow

Vincent DiRico

10:40 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

"it really is a 24/7 job. Even when school is out" -> really really?

Franklin

9:45 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

I know also of a vet teacher at WA (and coach) who opted to retire at the end of last year rather than continue teaching in a district/ building where teachers didnt seem to be valued anymore and contract language was disregarded by administration at a whim because their feelings were hurt...
My guess is the result of last year is many more staff asking their building administrator 'am I being asked or told' to do this? And if employees are being told to do things against contract language bring on the grievances!

Sarah

10:18 am on Friday, August 10, 2012

Olsen said it is not unusual for people to gauge their value to any organization to not only performance but compensation.

Humphrey believes that as long as the salaries are not competitive with other districts, the atmosphere in the school will remain the same.

"The professionalism of Westford educators will continue, but until the terms of our contract become more competitive with other districts like ours, the climate within our schools will remain tense," he wrote in an email.

"We will look for ways to improve working conditions in our schools, but until we feel we have a fair contract, our efforts will have a limited impact."

Rizzo

12:10 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

This makes me sad because I know some of the teachers who have left for more competitive salaries and they were great teachers. Too bad it had to come to this...

Jamaal

2:47 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Notice how when the WA VP went to Lexington (same position there $17k more) this summer there didn't even seem to be a conversation of saving the town $100 by leaving that position unfolded and letting WA be run by a Principal and 2 rather than 3 deans

minnie

4:01 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

I am not at all surprised by the teacher and administrator exodus from Westford. Their actions are direct result from the shoddy contract passed by the UNDERWHELMING vote of 181 to 129 in June. The superb reputation that once drew these talented professsionals to Westford has been drastically eroded causing the continued flight of highly successful educators into nearby school districts. Wisely, others will certainly leave. Consequently, the school system will be further diminished as less experienced (i.e. cheaper) teachers are hired to fill the gaps.
Encouraging and soothing words from the school committee cannot begin to correct the intangible harms done to the teachers as a whole. Afterall words are just that --
words. Still, I expect that the teachers will remain as professionals. They will do their duty but nothing more. The best we may expect for innovation, collaboration,
and inspiration has been pre-determined . It will be one percent. Westford loses.

Comment_arrow

Sam

11:10 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

An EXODUS, come on. We lose teachers every year. This is just more propaganda.

RM

4:44 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Maybe it's time for a change in School leadership here in town?

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

6:16 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

More likely an attempt at a prop 2 1/2 override.

MAHM3

9:04 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

The town has champagne taste on a beer budget!!! I think that about sums it up!

Vincent DiRico

10:53 pm on Friday, August 10, 2012

Hey queue the somber violin music.

I intend to help any effort to defeat an override. I for one am tired of all the sneaky posts with no names and extra tired of all the whining.

Vin DelSantos

1:46 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

I will lead the support for a prop 2 1/2 override then Vinny by rallying my friends who care more about excellent nationally ranked schools than another Market Basket, a few extra bucks is a small price to pay to retain the best LETS DO IT FOR THE CHILDREN

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

8:53 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

But one of the most important data points for the nationally ranked schools are the high test scores, which are driven by the Asians here in Westford. If you don't believe me, check out the MCAS scores by sub-category over the past 10 years. And those students will do well no matter who is in front of the classroom because their parents demand it.

RM

6:08 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Do we know if the Administrator who left was Stoney Brooks Principal Pete Cohen? We knew he was interviewing all over the place last year trying to get out of Westford and was a finalist in Lexington..,someone said he had one foot out the door but that it was the WA Administrator who found a much better paying job. Andrew can we confirm ?

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

8:55 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Adam Goldberg, the assistant principal at Westford Academy, is the one who is leaving.

Dan C

10:56 am on Saturday, August 11, 2012

The attitude of the current School Committee is that if teachers aren't happy in Westford after the town refuses to honor previously negotiated steps then they can leave , and what we are starting to see us exactly that- the better experienced teachers are beginning to flock for the exits and this WILL impact classroom experience of WPS students
Maybe the principals should understand above contract died a painful death last year and Olsen should be ready for more push back

Julie C.

1:59 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Olson "said teachers most likely to leave have between two to eight years' experience and are willing to lose their seniority to move into a district with a higher pay scale." according to the article in the Lowell Sun. Two to eight years' experience...hardly the better experienced teachers.

Comment_arrow

Randy Winslow

2:03 pm on Sunday, August 12, 2012

Uh-oh, then you will be left with only the hired paid teachers. Oh, the humanity! The taxpayers will all drown in their burdens.

dweir

2:52 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Adam Goldberg has been applying for positions since at least 2010, when he applied for the HS principal positions in Ashland and Hopkinton. The WA principal is young, so unless they move into a central office role, the only way for administrators to grow their careers is to go to other districts. This is not different than any other profession. There's only so much room at the top.

As for the teacher attrition, this very same argument with similar numbers was made every single year I was on the school committee from 2005-2008. And that was when we were giving double-digit raises.

Westford does a very poor job at promoting its total compensation package. The University of Westford program is a windfall for teachers who otherwise would need to pay for costly masters degree programs.

The UofW program was needed when the district experienced a growth boom and brought in many new teachers. Now, we face different challenges, including retaining top talent. But, salary growth can't happen without something else changing.

That something needs to be more than tax increases. I once proposed a salary schedule that would have paid $20K more than the current one. Tax increase was just part of it.

Prelude to an override: http://westfordforum.com/showthread.php/576-Prelude-to-an-override?p=3123#post3123

Comment_arrow

Randy Winslow

2:08 pm on Sunday, August 12, 2012

Diane, then why did the superintendent come out and say this? Especially after being so highly praised by the school committee? Not to mention that the UofW does nothing to help teachers get their masters degree, nor are any of the courses recognized by the DESE. When it comes time for recert or an upgrade of licensure, it best not say "UofW" on your certificate.

McGill

3:01 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Many (most?) other similar towns have a univ of Westford like system of PD that counts for advancement. AG took a job in Lexington that was the same position (not principal) for $17k more.
Next time Jim Antonelli sends his staff an email showing where WA ranks nationally and in the state maybe he ought to think about how his teachers feel being paid nowhere near there.... At times he is just as out of touch with his staff as his boss.

Comment_arrow

dweir

4:25 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Hi, McGill.

Whether or not other districts have a program like UofW is not as important as whether such a program is where we should be investing for the near term. I start with the premise that we can't simply keep adding on -- if not UofW, there may be other spending areas that made sense 10 yrs ago but that today are not a priority.

Sam

4:28 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Let's ask the 200 people lined up for each of the positions they are looking to fill if they are concerned that their base salary is less than Lexington. Let's get rid of these belly aching teachers. LET'S DO IT FOR THE CHILDREN

Comment_arrow

Randy Winslow

2:11 pm on Sunday, August 12, 2012

There are no positions in which 200 people applied. And when they realize the current situation most don't take the job.

Comment_arrow

Bill B

3:46 pm on Sunday, August 12, 2012

I am aware of a first choice candidate at WA who did not accept job in WPS last spring when he was briefed on the contract outlook in regard to SC denying steps for its teachers

dweir

4:47 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Some say that Westford's salaries should match the higher salaries offered in other towns. I did a quick calculation vs. Lexington and found that Westford's school budget would need to be increase by about $4M to equal the spending of Lexington.

I think that's just about what was asked for in 2005 -- $4M for the schools, $3M for the town for a total of $7M. Of course, that override failed. But the teacher's contract passed. And a similar contract passed three years later.

We don't know if the override had passed whether we would have seen significantly higher salaries. The contracts that passed both contained double-digit raises for many cells of the salary schedule.

But maybe we wouldn't have had the contentious negotiations this year. It was necessary for the SC to limit the raises in the new contract, but I don't think they should have withheld steps. They could have paid steps and then started negotiation with a 0% schedule adjustment. Back in 1990s when I was a teacher, a schedule adjustment was not an annual event!

But, back to Lexington v. Westford. Lexington's median household income is about 20% more than Westford's. Defeating the 2005 override helped keep Westford a bit more affordable. Maybe it doesn't make a difference for you, but it makes a difference for someone.

McGill

5:08 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Ok, Dweir I don't agree with everything you say but ican respect most of it especially your view that steps should have been paid and 0%COLA , not only do I think teachers would have understood that (yes, teachers view steps as a given but not cola) I think there wouldn't be the annimosity mistrust and illwill now between the 2 sides. Too bad the Keele Harkness contingent is not as reasonable as you serm

McGill

5:12 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Tom obviously doesn't understand PTS (professional teacher status) and dismissal statutes for PTS teachers, nor does he seem to believe in collective bargaining, labor laws, or contract rights -
Just because there is a guy more desperate for a job doesn't mean they don't care about salary and workers rights,

Sam

5:14 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Uh duhhh I no understand such things. Please leave the system an spare our kids your bitterness.

Patch_comments_icon

Andrew Sylvia

6:08 pm on Saturday, August 11, 2012

Reminder guys....talk to concepts, not each other.

Franklin

7:17 am on Monday, August 13, 2012

I don't think it changes anything drastically but there are a couple of teachers who are I believe are listed as leaving WPS as 'personal' and I know securing a better paying job elsewhere was a part of the reason to leave Westford- most likely they didn't feel as comfortable disclosing this in an exit interview

Comment_arrow

Vincent DiRico

7:28 am on Monday, August 13, 2012

I see a lot of effort in rumors, chest beating, ... If this effort went to the "24/7 requirement" (some of your ilk claim) then you'd be long gone and earning a lot more in a more "stable" system. Just some food for thought our turtle friend.

Kendra Kilsdonk

12:00 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

As Diane points out, the median family income in Lexington is much higher than that in Westford. In addition, median home price is $682K in Lexington vs $406K in Westford. Lexington also has a very high commercial property tax rate: $28.45 vs $15.55 in Westford. Individual tax rates are with in a percantage point of each other. It costs more to live within a short commute to Lexington, or you'd be spending more money ON commuting to stay in a more affordable area. Lexington has much more money to spend, Lexington costs more to live in or near...comparing salaries in these two towns is comparing apples and oranges.

Plus, the position that the former Assistant Principal from WA took in Lexington is that of Associate Principal...which is a promotion to a job with more responsibility, hence justifying the higher salary. Again, comparing apples to oranges.

Franklin

12:34 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

And Bill Olsen is now in on the spreading of these rumors?

Comment_arrow

Vincent DiRico

4:45 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

NO! just you, like this -> "I don't think it changes anything drastically but there are a couple of teachers who are I believe are listed as leaving WPS as 'personal' and I know securing a better paying job elsewhere was a part of the reason to leave Westford- most likely they didn't feel as comfortable disclosing this in an exit interview"

and on and on, ...

Franklin

12:54 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

The problem is its not only Lexington Westford is falling behind, Acton, Hudson, Groton (considering benefit split), Bedford etc all pay better, ALL the schools ranked by Boston Magazine in the top 25 pay better, Westford pay has fallen and continues to fall, well behind comfortable districts . Apples to apples

Comment_arrow

Julie C.

1:28 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

And yet 40 or so educators accepted positions here in Westford. And it does not appear that they are all "2nd or 3rd tier" candidates either, with degrees from Cornell, MIT, Harvard, Middlebury, Brown, William & Mary, Columbia, the US Naval Academy. Yup, Westford is really scraping the bottom of the barrel.

Kendra Kilsdonk

1:52 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

I wasn't actually addressing teacher salaries, as I'm not educated enough in that area to offer an opinion or statistics. I was addressing ONLY the use of an Assistant Principal leaving as potential evidence that Westford underpays school staff. Assistant Principal is not teaching staff, or part of the bargaining unit, and an administrator leaving for a higher ranking position in a higher profile (and wealthier) school district is hardly evidence that Westford didn't pay him enough. Most of us would consider new employment if it advanced our careers, which this has done for him.

Patch_comments_icon

Andrew Sylvia

4:52 pm on Monday, August 13, 2012

Okay, this has gone on long enough. Closing comments.

The editor has closed comments for this article.